The Mysterious Death of Carolyn Shultz: A Cold Case from 1969

Screenshot%202024 04 22%20at%2018.14.05

Carolyn Shultz, 38, was found dead in a hotel room in South Bend, Indiana, in April 1969. This was a terrible event. The town was shocked by her death, and many questions remain unsolved.

The Discovery:
On the morning of April 3, Dorothy Ford, who worked at the Marquette Hotel as a front desk clerk, made a terrible find. Dorothy went to look into it because a guest hadn't checked out. She used her master key to get into the room and found Carolyn's dead body inside. Carolyn was found naked and covered in blood, which shows that she had a fight.

The Autopsy:
An autopsy showed that Carolyn died because she had a lot of bleeding inside her body. She had serious injuries, including something stuck in her abdominal region. There were signs of blood and vomit all over the room, which suggests Carolyn moved after getting hurt. She died from her injuries, and it's thought that she had been dead for a few hours before she was found.


The Marquette Hotel:
The Marquette Hotel had a reputation for attracting a dubious clientele, known for its cheap rooms and association with criminal activities like drugs and prostitution. Despite this, Carolyn wasn't registered to the room where she was found. Instead, it was rented by an unidentified man, further deepening the mystery.

The Unidentified Man:
Described as a slender man in his mid-40s with dark hair and tanned skin, the man rented the room alone, claiming to be from Warsaw, Indiana. He was spotted conversing with Carolyn at a nearby tavern she frequented. Despite efforts to locate him, including inquiries at homeless shelters he reportedly visited, he remained elusive.

The Investigation:
While the circumstances surrounding Carolyn's death raised suspicions, authorities lacked concrete evidence to pursue a homicide investigation. The case remained open in hopes of identifying Carolyn's companion, but leads dried up, and the case went cold.


Carolyn's Life:
Carolyn had lived in South Bend for nearly three decades, raising six children with her husband, Robert. Her sudden and tragic death left a void in her family and the community. She was laid to rest in South Bend's Highland Cemetery, but justice remained elusive.

The death of Carolyn Shultz remains a haunting cold case, leaving unanswered questions and unresolved mysteries. Despite efforts by authorities and the community, her killer, and the circumstances surrounding her death, remain shrouded in darkness, a testament to the complexity of criminal investigations and the lasting impact of unsolved crimes.

Video Report:

Share this post on…

Subscribe to the newsletters: