1978 Murder Case: Former U.S. Soldier Arrested in German Woman's Death


In the quiet month of June 1978, a terrible crime happened in the cute German town of Ludwigsburg that will never be forgotten. An awful thing happened to 35-year-old Bärbel Gansau: she was brutally attacked in her own home and killed. Her death shocked everyone in the community. The details of that terrible night paint a horrifying picture: someone broke into Gansau's home by taking advantage of her harmless habit of leaving her window open for her cats. According to Gansau, what happened next was a nightmare beyond comprehension. She was repeatedly stabbed 37 times by her attacker, who eventually killed her.

A Crime Scene Haunted by Questions

As dawn broke, the grisly scene was discovered by a neighbor, Hugo Rehberg, who stumbled upon the aftermath of the savagery that had unfolded in Gansau's abode. The apartment, once a haven of comfort, lay in disarray, its tranquility shattered by the brutality of the crime. Detectives, tasked with unraveling the mystery, scoured the scene for clues, finding a lone fingerprint on Gansau's windowsill and two more within the confines of her home. Despite diligent efforts, the trail grew cold, leaving investigators grappling with unanswered questions and a community gripped by fear.

The Quest for Justice: Reopening the Investigation

Years turned into decades, but the specter of Gansau's murder lingered, casting a shadow over Ludwigsburg. It wasn't until 2020 that a glimmer of hope emerged as German authorities made the decision to reopen the case, buoyed by advancements in forensic technology. With renewed determination, investigators delved into the evidence, hopeful that modern techniques could breathe new life into the long-dormant investigation.

A Breakthrough in Forensic Science

The breakthrough came in the form of DNA evidence, a beacon of hope illuminating the path to justice. On January 29, 2021, the FBI delivered a revelation that reignited the pursuit of Gansau's killer: fingerprints recovered from the crime scene matched those of James Patrick Dempsey, a 22-year-old man arrested in the U.S. for a DUI shortly after the murder. Dempsey, a former U.S. soldier stationed in Ludwigsburg at the time of the crime, emerged as the primary suspect, thrusting the investigation into high gear.

Unveiling the Suspect's Troubled Past

As investigators delved deeper into Dempsey's past, a troubling portrait emerged. Army records revealed a history marked by alcoholism and aggressive behavior during his tenure as a soldier, painting a grim picture of a troubled individual grappling with inner demons. Further bolstering the case against Dempsey, DNA extracted from his trash yielded a match to samples found at the crime scene, solidifying his connection to Gansau's murder with a probability of 1 in 270 quadrillion.

The Wheels of Justice Turn

With Dempsey identified as the prime suspect, the wheels of justice began to turn inexorably. In June 2022, the Stuttgart lower court issued a warrant for Dempsey's arrest on charges of aggravated murder, paving the way for his extradition to Germany to stand trial. Despite the passage of over four decades, Dempsey's arrest on February 9, 2024, serves as a testament to the unwavering commitment of law enforcement to pursue justice, no matter the passage of time.

As Dempsey awaits his fate behind bars, the arrest marks a pivotal moment in the quest for closure for Bärbel Gansau's family and the community of Ludwigsburg. Though the scars of the past may never fully heal, the arrest of James Patrick Dempsey offers a glimmer of solace, a step towards accountability and resolution in a case that has long haunted those touched by its tragedy.


Share this post on…

Subscribe to the newsletters: